| Tab | Include |
|---|---|
| Lesson Plan | |
| Curriculum Standards | |
| Differentiated Learning | |
| Reference | |
| Questions & Answer Keys |
![]() |
|
| Dallas Zoological Society Partnership : Zoo Science Studying Animal Behavior |
|
Topic Overview
Quick Facts
Ethology is the study of behavior, and
ethologists can make ethograms to record the behavior of a specific animal.
According to Dr. Mark Briffa and Professor Bob
Elwood, hermit crabs show interesting behaviors when changing from one shell to
another; they will put their claws into a new shell to try to guage the size
and they will also pull sea anemones that have attatched themselves to the
crab’s old “home” (shell) off and attatch them to the new shell.
Domestic dogs have had a relationship with
people for thousands of years.
Animals have behaviors that help them meet basic
needs such as escaping predators, finding food and reproducing.
The killdeer bird has an interesting technique
for luring predators away from her nest.
Recent research by National Zoo scientists in Africa has shown that elephants form different kinds of
social groups, and individual elephants may move back and forth between groups.
Emporer penguins each have an individual call
that they can use to find their young.
It is possible for wild wolves and domestic dogs
to produce offspring, but this usually does not happen unless humans arrange
the conditions.
Mother animals are inspired to care for their
babies because of the way their babies’ bodies are designed; we think of this
as being “cute”.
Scientists at the Smithsonian National
Zoological Park
are using computers to teach orangutans a simple language.
Begin the Lesson
Ask the students to list examples in their of movements they
have completed, things they have said, made or written during the week. Have
the students compare their answers with a partner. Next, ask the students to
look up the definition of the word “behavior” in the dictionary. Tell the
students to rephrase the dictionary definition with a simpler one. Possible
answers might include:
Behavior is a response to something in your
environment.
Behavior is an action you take to do something.
Behavior helps you accomplish things you need to
do.
Whole Class Introduction to the Lesson
You will need at least one computer with Internet connectivity
and a projection device, a classroom with more than one computer, or access to
a computer lab. This introduction will take approximately 10 minutes to
complete.
Introduce your students to the concept of animal behavior by
visiting:
http://www.seaworld.org/animal-info/info-books/training/animal-behavior-&-learning.htm� If you are in a classroom with only one presentation station, ask the students to take turns reading the different sections on the Web site, starting with “Definition of Behavior.” There are many sections on this sight, so you might want to pick just a few, depending on the students’ previous learning. Ask the students how many have ever seen an animal show like the ones at Sea World. Sample Questions
How do the trainers get the killer whales and
other animals to perform in the show? They use whistles, or hand signals, and
offer them rewards.
How do you think these actions are different
from those performed in the wild? In the wild, they don’t have all the
equipment that they do in the show, like hoops to jump through, but some of the
same actions might happen in the wild. For example, dolphins and killer whales
jumping out of the water.
As part of the introduction, you may want to review some of the
glossary terms in advance of students going online. At this point you can
launch the WebLesson as whole-class activity using a projection device, or you
can assign students to work individually or in teams in a computer lab.
WebLesson Sites
Introduction Ethology is the study of behavior. We can make ethograms to show how animals behave. It is easy to think of some simple examples for humans. Wrestling with your little brother, eating lunch, doing homework, and playing football can all be considered behaviors. If you have pets, you have probably noticed they also have certain habits at certain times of the day. Behaviors allow animals to satisfy hunger, escape other animals, and have relationships with others of their own species. Mating behaviors allow for reproduction. Scientists have many different methods for studying behavior, some of which are general while others are specialized for certain animals. In this lesson, you will learn about what different behaviors can help animals do and how scientists study those behaviors. The knowledge they gain can keep species in the wild from disappearing.
Scenario You are a member of a special science exploration team, which will study a forest that has been seen by few humans. While traveling, you have been marooned on a remote island. Unfortunately, you cannot locate your team and you begin to tour the island and evaluate your situation. Just beyond a grove of palm trees, you notice some animals you have never seen before. They appear to be a group that can communicate with each other by using jumps, gestures and signs with their front limbs, but you cannot immediately figure out their system. You decide that it would be best to find a quiet spot to hide and observe these Strange Island Animals, or S.I.A.’s for a while.
Lesson Pages
Diary of a Zoo Leader in Training
http://nationalzoo.si.edu/AboutUs/BehindTheScenes/FujifilmResident/July07.cfm
Emperor Penguin, Emperor Penguin Profile
http://animals.nationalgeographic.com/animals/birds/emperor-penguin.html?nav=FEATURES Rich Media
Nature-Alien Empire-Voyagers
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/episodes/alien-empire/monarch-butterfly-migration/3420/ Rich Media
Polar Bears International-Bear Facts
http://www.polarbearsinternational.org/bear-facts/bathing-habits/
International Wolf Center-Learn-Communication
http://www.wolf.org/wolves/learn/basic/biology/communication.asp
Spider Courtship
http://cas.bellarmine.edu/tietjen/Animal%20Behavior/RabidosaRabida.htm Primary Source
Animal Reproduction: Two Different Methods
http://videos.howstuffworks.com/hsw/20528-animal-reproduction-two-different-methods-video.htm Rich Media
Killdeer fakes a broken wing
http://www.birdcinema.com/view_video.php?viewkey=9f04d16ce31165e139a4 Rich Media
Seirian Sumner-Research Fellow-Meet the Team-Discovery & Learning-ZSL
http://www.zsl.org/discovery-learning/meet-the-team/seirian-sumner-research-fellow,500,AR.html
Think Tank Exhibit-National Zoo-FONZ
http://nationalzoo.si.edu/Animals/ThinkTank/Exhibit/default.cfm Conclusion & Project
Conclusion It seems as if there are as many animal behaviors as there are animals. Some behaviors are carried out because animals need to meet their basic needs. Examples of this would be keeping fur clean, or flying south to stay warm, or a male fish carrying eggs in his mouth so they will be safe until they hatch so the species will survive. Communication is also very important to some species, like wolves, chimpanzees, and humans. For some animals, communication starts very early with babies giving their mothers wide-eyed looks or sad faces. These behaviors can help mothers take good care of their babies so that they will survive. If a member of a wolf pack or chimpanzee family sends the wrong signals, they could miss a meal or an opportunity to mate. New technology can help scientists find out more about how groups of animals interact with each other. If orangutans can learn to speak by using a computer, we may actually be able to find out if other species are able to have thoughts just like humans. The more we learn about animal behavior the better we can help different animal species survive.
Project Now that you have learned about some animal behaviors and their possible meanings, it is time for you to try to navigate your temporary island home. Use your imagination and the examples of animal behavior you have seen in the lesson to write a sample ethogram for the Strange Island Animals. The ethogram should be written from 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. Begin with an introductory paragraph that describes the island and the creatures. Ask yourself questions like-“How big are their heads? “or “How many eyes, ears, arms, and legs do they have? “ Next, list the time, and underneath the time, write a sample of what you might observe the S.I.A’s doing. Think about different types of animal behaviors and why the animals would need to perform certain behaviors.
Glossary
harmoniously - peacefully
intentions - action that you take on purpose
facilitate - to make progress
repertoire - set of skills or normal actions
interior - inside
physiological - having to do with the chemical reactions in the body
enlisting - asking for help
astounded - surprised
insulator - material that can hold heat
carcass - dead body
mammalian - having to do with mammals
shoal - group
regurgitation - bringing food back up from the stomach
elicit - produce
oscillogram - picture of an electrical wave
malathion - spray that kills insects
shimmying - shaking
livebearing - mother gives birth to already formed babies instead of laying eggs
evolution - change in species over time
allure - wanting to be closer to something
exhibit - show
juvenile - young
acclaimed - praised
accessible - easy to reach or understand
alliance - friendship
intricate - complex or made of many layers
|
| Dallas Zoological Society Partnership : Zoo Science Studying Animal Behavior Introduction
Introduction Ethology is the study of behavior. We can make ethograms to show how animals behave. It is easy to think of some simple examples for humans. Wrestling with your little brother, eating lunch, doing homework, and playing football can all be considered behaviors. If you have pets, you have probably noticed they also have certain habits at certain times of the day. Behaviors allow animals to...
|
Lesson PlanTopic Overview
Quick Facts
Ethology is the study of behavior, and
ethologists can make ethograms to record the behavior of a specific animal.
According to Dr. Mark Briffa and Professor Bob
Elwood, hermit crabs show interesting behaviors when changing from one shell to
another; they will put their claws into a new shell to try to guage the size
and they will also pull sea anemones that have attatched themselves to the
crab’s old “home” (shell) off and attatch them to the new shell.
Domestic dogs have had a relationship with
people for thousands of years.
Animals have behaviors that help them meet basic
needs such as escaping predators, finding food and reproducing.
The killdeer bird has an interesting technique
for luring predators away from her nest.
Recent research by National Zoo scientists in Africa has shown that elephants form different kinds of
social groups, and individual elephants may move back and forth between groups.
Emporer penguins each have an individual call
that they can use to find their young.
It is possible for wild wolves and domestic dogs
to produce offspring, but this usually does not happen unless humans arrange
the conditions.
Mother animals are inspired to care for their
babies because of the way their babies’ bodies are designed; we think of this
as being “cute”.
Scientists at the Smithsonian National
Zoological Park
are using computers to teach orangutans a simple language.
Begin the Lesson
Ask the students to list examples in their of movements they
have completed, things they have said, made or written during the week. Have
the students compare their answers with a partner. Next, ask the students to
look up the definition of the word “behavior” in the dictionary. Tell the
students to rephrase the dictionary definition with a simpler one. Possible
answers might include:
Behavior is a response to something in your
environment.
Behavior is an action you take to do something.
Behavior helps you accomplish things you need to
do.
Whole Class Introduction to the Lesson
You will need at least one computer with Internet connectivity
and a projection device, a classroom with more than one computer, or access to
a computer lab. This introduction will take approximately 10 minutes to
complete.
Introduce your students to the concept of animal behavior by
visiting:
http://www.seaworld.org/animal-info/info-books/training/animal-behavior-&-learning.htm� If you are in a classroom with only one presentation station, ask the students to take turns reading the different sections on the Web site, starting with “Definition of Behavior.” There are many sections on this sight, so you might want to pick just a few, depending on the students’ previous learning. Ask the students how many have ever seen an animal show like the ones at Sea World. Sample Questions
How do the trainers get the killer whales and
other animals to perform in the show? They use whistles, or hand signals, and
offer them rewards.
How do you think these actions are different
from those performed in the wild? In the wild, they don’t have all the
equipment that they do in the show, like hoops to jump through, but some of the
same actions might happen in the wild. For example, dolphins and killer whales
jumping out of the water.
As part of the introduction, you may want to review some of the
glossary terms in advance of students going online. At this point you can
launch the WebLesson as whole-class activity using a projection device, or you
can assign students to work individually or in teams in a computer lab.
WebLesson Sites
Introduction Ethology is the study of behavior. We can make ethograms to show how animals behave. It is easy to think of some simple examples for humans. Wrestling with your little brother, eating lunch, doing homework, and playing football can all be considered behaviors. If you have pets, you have probably noticed they also have certain habits at certain times of the day. Behaviors allow animals to satisfy hunger, escape other animals, and have relationships with others of their own species. Mating behaviors allow for reproduction. Scientists have many different methods for studying behavior, some of which are general while others are specialized for certain animals. In this lesson, you will learn about what different behaviors can help animals do and how scientists study those behaviors. The knowledge they gain can keep species in the wild from disappearing.
Scenario You are a member of a special science exploration team, which will study a forest that has been seen by few humans. While traveling, you have been marooned on a remote island. Unfortunately, you cannot locate your team and you begin to tour the island and evaluate your situation. Just beyond a grove of palm trees, you notice some animals you have never seen before. They appear to be a group that can communicate with each other by using jumps, gestures and signs with their front limbs, but you cannot immediately figure out their system. You decide that it would be best to find a quiet spot to hide and observe these Strange Island Animals, or S.I.A.’s for a while.
Lesson Pages
Diary of a Zoo Leader in Training
http://nationalzoo.si.edu/AboutUs/BehindTheScenes/FujifilmResident/July07.cfm
Emperor Penguin, Emperor Penguin Profile
http://animals.nationalgeographic.com/animals/birds/emperor-penguin.html?nav=FEATURES Rich Media
Nature-Alien Empire-Voyagers
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/episodes/alien-empire/monarch-butterfly-migration/3420/ Rich Media
Polar Bears International-Bear Facts
http://www.polarbearsinternational.org/bear-facts/bathing-habits/
International Wolf Center-Learn-Communication
http://www.wolf.org/wolves/learn/basic/biology/communication.asp
Spider Courtship
http://cas.bellarmine.edu/tietjen/Animal%20Behavior/RabidosaRabida.htm Primary Source
Animal Reproduction: Two Different Methods
http://videos.howstuffworks.com/hsw/20528-animal-reproduction-two-different-methods-video.htm Rich Media
Killdeer fakes a broken wing
http://www.birdcinema.com/view_video.php?viewkey=9f04d16ce31165e139a4 Rich Media
Seirian Sumner-Research Fellow-Meet the Team-Discovery & Learning-ZSL
http://www.zsl.org/discovery-learning/meet-the-team/seirian-sumner-research-fellow,500,AR.html
Think Tank Exhibit-National Zoo-FONZ
http://nationalzoo.si.edu/Animals/ThinkTank/Exhibit/default.cfm Conclusion & Project
Conclusion It seems as if there are as many animal behaviors as there are animals. Some behaviors are carried out because animals need to meet their basic needs. Examples of this would be keeping fur clean, or flying south to stay warm, or a male fish carrying eggs in his mouth so they will be safe until they hatch so the species will survive. Communication is also very important to some species, like wolves, chimpanzees, and humans. For some animals, communication starts very early with babies giving their mothers wide-eyed looks or sad faces. These behaviors can help mothers take good care of their babies so that they will survive. If a member of a wolf pack or chimpanzee family sends the wrong signals, they could miss a meal or an opportunity to mate. New technology can help scientists find out more about how groups of animals interact with each other. If orangutans can learn to speak by using a computer, we may actually be able to find out if other species are able to have thoughts just like humans. The more we learn about animal behavior the better we can help different animal species survive.
Project Now that you have learned about some animal behaviors and their possible meanings, it is time for you to try to navigate your temporary island home. Use your imagination and the examples of animal behavior you have seen in the lesson to write a sample ethogram for the Strange Island Animals. The ethogram should be written from 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. Begin with an introductory paragraph that describes the island and the creatures. Ask yourself questions like-“How big are their heads? “or “How many eyes, ears, arms, and legs do they have? “ Next, list the time, and underneath the time, write a sample of what you might observe the S.I.A’s doing. Think about different types of animal behaviors and why the animals would need to perform certain behaviors.
Glossary
harmoniously - peacefully
intentions - action that you take on purpose
facilitate - to make progress
repertoire - set of skills or normal actions
interior - inside
physiological - having to do with the chemical reactions in the body
enlisting - asking for help
astounded - surprised
insulator - material that can hold heat
carcass - dead body
mammalian - having to do with mammals
shoal - group
regurgitation - bringing food back up from the stomach
elicit - produce
oscillogram - picture of an electrical wave
malathion - spray that kills insects
shimmying - shaking
livebearing - mother gives birth to already formed babies instead of laying eggs
evolution - change in species over time
allure - wanting to be closer to something
exhibit - show
juvenile - young
acclaimed - praised
accessible - easy to reach or understand
alliance - friendship
intricate - complex or made of many layers
|
Curriculum StandardsTEXAS
112.22. Science, Grade 6
(2) Scientific processes. The student uses scientific inquiry methods during field and laboratory investigations. The student is expected to: (A) plan and implement investigative procedures including asking questions, formulating testable hypotheses, and selecting and using equipment and technology; (B) collect data by observing and measuring; (C) analyze and interpret information to construct reasonable explanations from direct and indirect evidence; (D) communicate valid conclusions; and (E) construct graphs, tables, maps, and charts using tools including computers to organize, examine, and evaluate data. (3) Scientific processes. The student uses critical thinking and scientific problem solving to make informed decisions. The student is expected to: (A) analyze, review, and critique scientific explanations, including hypotheses and theories, as to their strengths and weaknesses using scientific evidence and information; 112.23. Science, Grade 7 (2) Scientific processes. The student uses scientific inquiry methods during field and laboratory investigations. The student is expected to: (A) plan and implement investigative procedures including asking questions, formulating testable hypotheses, and selecting and using equipment and technology; (B) collect data by observing and measuring; (C) organize, analyze, make inferences, and predict trends from direct and indirect evidence; (D) communicate valid conclusions; and (E) construct graphs, tables, maps, and charts using tools including computers to organize, examine, and evaluate data. (3) Scientific processes. The student uses critical thinking and scientific problem solving to make informed decisions. The student is expected to: (A) analyze, review, and critique scientific explanations, including hypotheses and theories, as to their strengths and weaknesses using scientific evidence and information; 112.24. Science, Grade 8 (2) Scientific processes. The student uses scientific inquiry methods during field and laboratory investigations. The student is expected to: (A) plan and implement investigative procedures including asking questions, formulating testable hypotheses, and selecting and using equipment and technology; (B) collect data by observing and measuring; (C) organize, analyze, evaluate, make inferences, and predict trends from direct and indirect evidence; (D) communicate valid conclusions; and (E) construct graphs, tables, maps, and charts using tools including computers to organize, examine, and evaluate data. (3) Scientific processes. The student uses critical thinking and scientific problem solving to make informed decisions. The student is expected to: (A) analyze, review, and critique scientific explanations, including hypotheses and theories, as to their strengths and weaknesses using scientific evidence and information; 112.43. Biology (2) Scientific processes. The student uses scientific methods during field and laboratory investigations. The student is expected to: (A) plan and implement investigative procedures including asking questions, formulating testable hypotheses, and selecting equipment and technology; (B) collect data and make measurements with precision; (C) organize, analyze, evaluate, make inferences, and predict trends from data; and (D) communicate valid conclusions. (3) Scientific processes. The student uses critical thinking and scientific problem solving to make informed decisions. The student is expected to: (A) analyze, review, and critique scientific explanations, including hypotheses and theories, as to their strengths and weaknesses using scientific evidence and information 7) Science concepts. The student knows the theory of biological evolution. The student is expected to: (B) illustrate the results of natural selection in speciation, diversity, phylogeny, adaptation, behavior, and extinction. NATIONAL
NS.5-8.1 SCIENCE AS INQUIRY
As a result of activities in grades 5-8, all students should develop: *Abilities necessary to do scientific inquiry *Understandings about scientific inquiry NS.5-8.3 LIFE SCIENCE As a result of their activities in grades 5-8, all students should develop understanding: *Structure and function in living systems *Regulation and behavior |
Differentiated LearningHere are some projects that can be used after the students have
completed the online assignment or as a complement to your lesson. The students
can use any media deemed appropriate for the project. Each has been recommended
with specific student groups in mind.
AS-All Students
GT-Gifted/Talented
ESL-English Second
Language
SN-Special Needs
Individual and Group Projects
Observe an animal near your home, such as a pet,
a friend’s pet, or a nonpoisonous bug or earthworm that you might find in a
garden. Record behaviors that you see. Observe a pet for four hours; observe
something in your back yard or garden for two hours. Be sure to get your
parents’ permission to go outside and take any necessary weather precautions,
such as wearing sunscreen. AS, ESL
Make a poster that features three famous
zoologists, biologists, or ethologists. Find three biographical facts and three
facts about their research. Use articles from library research or the internet.
Write a reference list on notebook paper and tape it to the back of the poster.
AS, ESL, SN
Visit a local zoo or aquarium and interview a
staff member about any animal behavior projects that are happening there.
Present your findings to the class in an oral report or PowerPoint
Presentation. GT, AS
Make a poster or PowerPoint Presentation that
shows examples of basic animal behaviors (escaping predators, social groups
with leaders, or courtship). You may include humans, and you must have at least
5 different animals. AS, ESL, SN
Final Project – Whole Class
Divide the class into groups of four to five students. Give
each group an animal to research: wolves, honeybees, seahorses, chimpanzees,
tigers, and bats would all be good choices. Give the students two class days to
research the behavior of these animals: their social structure, what they eat,
how they avoid their predators and how they reproduce. Once the students
complete their research, have them make up a game in which the players are
faced with making a decision and must make the right one to survive. For
example:
You are an 18 month old male wolf, one of the
smallest in the pack. The largest oldest male is walking toward you, snarling.
Do you snarl back, run to attack him, or lie down on your stomach?
The game can be any format, but you must approve their design
before they begin their construction. The game must include a set of rules and
directions on how to keep score. When all of the groups finish their games,
have an Animal Behavior Tournament. Each group should rotate from game to game
so they can learn about the different types of animals that were researched.
|
ReferenceBiographies
Steve Irwin
http://www.crocodilehunter.com.au/crocodile_hunter/ about_steve_terri/steve_biography.html Sketch of the Crocodile Hunter completed before his death in September of 2006 Jane Goodall
http://www.janegoodall.org/jane/default.asp Woman that has devoted her life to studying chimpanzees in Africa Dian Fossey
http://www.gorillafund.org/dian_fossey/ Scientist who did extensive research on mountain gorillas in Africa and worked to prevent poaching Karl von Frisch
http://nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/medicine/ laureates/1973/frisch-autobio.html Studied the senses of bees and interpreted the “waggle dance” performed by bees Timelines
Milwaukee County Zoo History
http://www.milwaukeezoo.org/bartlett_society.html Comprehensive zoo history website St. Louis Zoo Timeline
http://www.stlzoo.org/home/history/ Interactive timeline highlighting major events in the development of the St. Louis Zoo Oregon Zoo Timeline
http://www.metro-region.org/article.cfm?ArticleID=2935 History of the development of the Washington Park Zoo, now called the Oregon Zoo San Diego Zoo History
http://www.sandiegozoo.org/kids/readaboutit_zoo_history.html Description of the founding of the San Diego Zoo Additional Information
Animal Behavior Society
http://www.animalbehavior.org/ABSEducation/laboratory-exercises- in-animal-behavior/laboratory-exercises-in-animal-behavior-ethograms/ Description of Ethograms with example exercise that can be completed with laboratory mice Michael D. Breed
http://www.animalbehavioronline.com/7.html Detailed information on different types of foraging in animals Teachers’ Domain
http://www.teachersdomain.org/resources/tdc02/ sci/life/reg/lp_findfood/index.html Features activity that students can do on foraging; registration is required for viewing the videos Philadelphia
Zoo
http://www.philadelphiazoo.org/wildlifematters/ mar07/featuredstory1.html Brief article about the conflict between elephants and humans when their habitats are too close together Bill Hilton, Jr
http://www.rubythroat.org/ Information and opportunities to participate in activities and inter-school, multi-state projects that involve the Ruby Throated Hummingbird Access Excellence
http://www.accessexcellence.org/AE/AEC/ AEF/1994/peebles_behavior.html Describes how to make an Ethogram; it is designed for high school students Lester
B. Pearson
College of the Pacific
http://www.racerocks.com/racerock/education/ethology/sunny.htm Sample Sea Lion Ethogram PBS
http://www.pbs.org/safarchive/4_class/45_ pguides/pguide_504/4554_chimp.html Archived Teacher’s Guide includes activities for observing animal behavior and making ethograms The Xerces Society
http://www.xerces.org/Pollinator_Insect_ Conservation/biology.htm#solitary Information about different types of bees; some bees are members of social groups and some bees are solitary |
Questions & Answer KeysStudy Questions and Answer Keys
Quiz Questions & Answers
Project
Now that you have learned about some animal behaviors and their possible meanings, it is time for you to try to navigate your temporary island home. Use your imagination and the examples of animal behavior you have seen in the lesson to write a sample ethogram for the Strange Island Animals. The ethogram should be written from 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. Begin with an introductory paragraph that describes the island and the creatures. Ask yourself questions like-“How big are their heads? “or “How many eyes, ears, arms, and legs do they have? “ Next, list the time, and underneath the time, write a sample of what you might observe the S.I.A’s doing. Think about different types of animal behaviors and why the animals would need to perform certain behaviors.
Rubric
Excellent (30 – 20)
An excellent student response meets all the project requirements and demonstrates that the student absorbed key lesson concepts and gave them thoughtful consideration. The response shows original thinking, creativity, and a strong sense of purpose. Ideas are organized and clearly articulated according to the proper conventions of writing (at this grade level).
Satisfactory (20 – 10)
A satisfactory student response meets most of the project requirements but overlooks one or more important elements. It reflects a general understanding of the key lesson concepts but shows little depth. The response shows little creativity or originality. Ideas are somewhat disorganized and difficult to follow, and there are numerous grammatical and mechanical errors.
Needs Improvement (10 – 0)
The student response is perfunctory, showing little or no effort. It is unclear if the student thought about or even read any of the lesson content. Ideas are scattered or off-topic. If possible, ask the student to revisit the lesson with a peer or mentor and then rewrite his or her response. |